Crowd Cow Reviews

Crowd Cow has an overall rating of 2.3 based on 22 reviews. Customer feedback on Crowd Cow is mixed: Crowd Cow reviewers highlight positive aspects like high-quality meat, excellent customer service, convenient delivery options, diverse selection of cuts, which strongly appeal to meat enthusiasts, health-conscious consumers, foodies, individuals seeking premium products. However, Crowd Cow is often criticized for its higher price point, limited shipping areas, occasional delivery delays, subscription model may not suit everyone.

2.3/5.0

22 reviews

5 Stars

0

4 Stars

2

3 Stars

7

2 Stars

1

1 Star

6

All Crowd Cow Reviews (22)
henry_Jones00
May 24, 2026
"Refund took a little while, but they fixed it"
I ordered from them because my sister had used them before and had a decent experience, so I figured I’d give it a shot. My order ended up arriving later than expected, and one of the packs was banged up when it got here, which was frustrating.
I emailed customer support and didn’t hear back for a couple of days, so that part was a bit annoying. Once they did respond, they explained what had happened and offered a refund for the damaged item. I did have to send one follow-up, but after that it was straightforward.

Overall, it wasn’t the smoothest experience, but they did take care of it in the end. I’d probably order again if I wasn’t in a hurry, especially since my sister’s order went fine, but I’d keep my expectations realistic
rogersantillan0823
May 14, 2026
"Shipping was reliable"
My box showed up cold and right on the day I expected it . One tracking update was a little late , but overall it felt dependable ...
DouglasTurner_31
May 13, 2026
"Sooo underwhelmed by the flavor"
I ordered from Crowd Cow thinking the meat would be a noticeable step up from what I usually grab at the grocery store, but honestlyyy, it just wasn’t. The steaks looked nice when they arrived, and I was excited to cook them, but once they were done, the flavor was really flat and kind of boring.
For the price, I expected wayyy more. My family ate some of it, but nobody was excited about it, and the leftovers just sat there because no one wanted them. I don’t think I’d order again.
WmRodriguez_83
May 07, 2026
"I ordered from Crowd Cow and..."
I ordered from Crowd Cow and it was fine, not bad, not amazing, just kind of there. The meat tasted okay and nothing seemed off, so I’ll give them that, but for the price I was expecting it to feel a lot fresher. Shipping was also perfectly acceptable, which is about as exciting as it sounds. I might give them another shot at some point, but this order definitely didn’t blow me away.
ryan.Graham
May 06, 2026
"Hard to Pin Down the Actual Source"
I couldn’t really tell where the info was coming from. The sourcing felt vague, and I’d feel a lot better if it was clearer and more direct.
margueritehiggins0287
April 15, 2026
"I had an issue and reached out..."
I had an issue and reached out to customer service, but it didn’t feel like they were trying to fix anything. I kept getting short, canned-sounding replies that didn’t really answer my questions. The whole thing felt more like polished company talk than actual help from a real person. Frustrating, to be honest.
MAGERA
April 15, 2026
"Good overall, but my gut says there’s room to improve"
I’ve had a decent experience with Crowd Cow. They do have some solid meat options, and a few things definitely looked worth trying. But my gut feeling is that the selection can be a little inconsistent. Sometimes I’d find what I wanted, and other times the cuts I was hoping for were either missing or out of stock. It’s not a bad service by any means, I just wish it felt a bit more reliable and had a wider variety
GONZALES
April 07, 2026
"The meat was literally kind of disappointing"
I was hoping the meat would be better, but it was literally tough and didn’t have much flavor. Kind of a letdown...
Shawnta-ness
April 05, 2026
"Box showed up leaking and the apology felt copied and pasted"
My box arrived soggy, torn, and leaking, and the meat was already half thawed. I reached out hoping for some actual help, but the response felt like one of those canned “sorry for the inconvenience” messages. Frustrating when the food shows up in bad shape and all you get back is a generic apology.
BERGER
March 27, 2026
"I like that you can skip boxes when..."
I like that you can skip boxes when you need to, because some weeks my fridge is already packed with random stuff I forgot I bought. Changing the delivery dates was a little more confusing than I expected, though. I eventually figured it out, but it definitely took longer than it should have.
tracie1995
March 15, 2026
"Delivery took forever"
The delivery was way slower than I expected. I kept checking the tracking like every couple of hours, which is probably not healthy, but you know how it is when you're waiting on something. I even ended up cleaning part of my kitchen while waiting, which I almost never do unless I'm avoiding something else. Anyway, it finally showed up, but the wait was frustrating.
delores1999
March 09, 2026
"The meat itself was really good and..."
The meat itself was really good and everything showed up in good shape, so no complaints there. But the portions felt smaller than what I was expecting for the price. A few of the cuts looked a lot more generous in the photos, which made it kind of frustrating once I was actually cooking for my family. It’s not a bad order overall, but it would help if the serving sizes were shown a bit more clearly so people know what they’re really getting
Robert-thompson
January 23, 2026
"My Crowd Cow order showed up when..."
My Crowd Cow order showed up when it was supposed to, but the timing was still kind of inconvenient for me that day, so I was already a little annoyed dealing with it. Most of the order was right, but one of the steak packs wasn’t the one I picked. Not the end of the world, and the quality was fine, but it’s still frustrating when you plan around a delivery and then have to notice something’s off. I might order again, but I really wish they’d double-check the box better before sending it out
David-neace
January 05, 2026
"Pretty easy to use, just a couple little hiccups"
Crowd Cow’s site was easy to navigate. I found what I was looking for without too much hassle, and the checkout process was really straightforward. A few pages did load a little slow for me, and the filters could definitely be better, but overall it was super simple to use.
marina_Dawson91
January 01, 2026
"Not sure it was worth the cost"
I tried Crowd Cow once, and I don’t know, I was kind of expecting more for the price. The meat was fine, I guess, definitely not bad, but it didn’t really feel special enough to justify what I paid. The portions felt a little small too, and once shipping was added, it just seemed overpriced. I can probably get similar quality from local places for less, so I don’t think I’ll order again
SaraWhaley
December 06, 2025
"Box was kind of warm, right?"
When it arrived, the box felt warmer than I expected, and the ice was pretty much mostly melted. Maybe that’s not a huge deal, but I feel like it should have stayed colder during delivery, right?

View More Reviews

Crowd Cow Q&A

Both reviews from same person and 3rd from yet another Michael... NOT buying it...

Have a question about Crowd Cow?

Customer Reviews

Questions & Answers

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.